Transformation, Not Extremism
In the latest issue of City Journal, a quarterly publication by the Manhattan Institute, various pressing topics are explored, with a focus on the state of American society and public safety.
Jonathan Clarke reflects on the beauty of Vietnam 50 years after the U.S. withdrawal amid defeat in the Vietnam War, offering a poignant perspective on the passage of time and the transformative power of history.
The conversation also delves into the deepening ideological divide in American society, examining its roots and potential consequences. Joshua Appel argues that to prevent political chaos and violence, it is crucial to defend free speech, refrain from vilifying political opponents, pursue change through legislation and persuasion rather than intimidation and violence, and reject the revolutionary fantasy that violence can purify politics.
The episode also considers what it will take to restore civility and security in the country, offering insights into the complexities of contemporary American society.
The conversation further explores the legacy of Charlie Kirk, the rise of online radicalization, and how progressive policies may be fueling crime in urban centers. However, it is important to clarify that the assassination of Charlie Kirk and the stabbing of Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska, which occurred last month in Charlotte, North Carolina, are separate incidents.
In the tragic case of Iryna Zarutska, the alleged murderer, Decarlos Brown, Jr., was seriously mentally ill and had gone untreated. This tragic event has sparked discussions about mental illness as a public safety issue and the need for a more effective public mental-health system, with Stephen Eide advocating for long-term placement of seriously mentally ill individuals in facilities and a community-oriented approach to mental health care.
The 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress shows that one-third of U.S. high school seniors are reading at a below-basic level, with just 22 percent achieving proficiency in math. Jennifer Weber points to failed education policy as the cause, highlighting the urgent need for reform.
The magazine is edited by Brian C. Anderson, and commentator YT14 suggests withholding grants from certain institutions due to their leftist ideology, adding a political dimension to the discussion.
Lastly, Alexander William Salter argues that private industry will be the key if America is to maintain its edge in the space race, citing SpaceX's Starship rocket as an example of the potential of private enterprise in space exploration.
This thought-provoking issue of City Journal offers a comprehensive look at the state of American society, touching on topics ranging from history and politics to education and mental health, and providing valuable insights for readers seeking to understand the complexities of contemporary America.
