Shifts in Labor Law: Can Home Be the New Office?
Pondering Resignation Alternatives: Can Working from Home Be an Option?
Quick Facts Facebook Twitter WhatsApp Email Print Copy Link
In today's world, the idea of a traditional office might seem like a relic from the past. When a workplace moves, some may dream of telecommuting, but the cold hard truth is that it's not always the employer's responsibility to accommodate this imagining. A ruling from the Labor Court of Appeal Stuttgart (AZ.: 9 Sa 42/24) enlightens us on this matter, as clarified by the Working Group on Labor Law of the German Bar Association (DAV).
In particular, an employer electing to close a branch issued a change of location notice to an employee, who didn't approve. Instead, the employee demanded a home office assignment. The employee challenged the change of location notice with a lawsuit, aiming to invalidate the alteration in work conditions through said notice.
Earning an average monthly gross salary of 5,620.53 euros, the plaintiff lost their workplace due to the branch's closure.
Home Office Not Mandatory, But Not Off the Table
The lawsuit was struck down by the Labor Court Villingen-Schwenningen, and the appeal to the Labor Court of Appeal Stuttgart was likewise denied. Due to the employee's workplace being eliminated upon the branch's closure, the dismissal was deemed socially justifiable.
Simply put, the employer was allowed to require the employee to continue doing the job at the new location, as long as a business restructuring was in play. A home office position would have been necessary if it were already stated in the contract or widely practiced within the company, but the court found that such a setup wasn't obligated in the case at hand.
An appeal on points of law has since been filed with the Federal Labor Court (Az.: 2 AZR 302/24).
While German labor law doesn't compel employers to provide home office positions in all situations, they are encouraged to take employees' rights and needs into account, particularly in relation to flexible work arrangements. Employers are more and more offering remote working perks, which often incorporate home offices, as part of these flexible work arrangements. Although not a legal requirement, it's becoming increasingly popular, particularly within industries dominated by desk work[3].
Regarding a workplace relocation scenario, employers must evaluate the impact on employees and possibly negotiate alternative arrangements via employment contracts or collective agreements. However, there's no general legal requirement to offer a home office as a lone alternative to a relocation.
Additionally, when an employer asks employees to utilize their personal digital equipment for work, such as in a home office setup, they generally must equip employees with the essential digital work tools unless there's an agreement in place to waive this obligation[1].
Ultimately, while employers in Germany don't have to offer a home office in every situation, they must engage in honest negotiations and weigh the needs of employees when making changes like relocations.
- Legal Questions
- Moving Business
- Home Office Options
- Employee Lawsuits
- Workplace Relocation
- Labor Court Rulings
- Digital Work Tools
- Employment Contracts
- Collective Agreements
- Employer-Employee Relationship
Additional Insights:
In German labor law, employers and employees need to function in good faith and respect the needs and rights of the workforce. While home office arrangements aren't compulsory in every case, employers must exhibit a degree of flexibility in seeking fair alternatives, particularly in the face of substantial changes like relocations.
- The ruling from the Labor Court of Appeal Stuttgart highlighted that while German law does not mandate home office positions in all cases, employers are encouraged to consider employee rights and needs, especially in relation to flexible work arrangements.
- It was noted that, whereas employers are not legally required to offer a home office as the sole alternative to a relocation, they must evaluate the impact on employees and potentially negotiate alternative arrangements through employment contracts or collective agreements.
- In scenarios where an employer requires employees to use their personal digital equipment for work in a home office setup, they generally have an obligation to provide essential digital work tools, unless there is an agreement in place to waive this responsibility.
