In Tudor England, the most common unintentional cause of death reveals fascinating insights into everyday existence
===============================================================================
In Tudor England, drowning was the most frequent cause of accidental death, accounting for approximately 40% of all such incidents recorded in coroners’ inquests during the 16th century [1]. This high incidence can be attributed to the everyday risks people faced in their interactions with waterways, as many lived and worked near or on rivers, lakes, and other bodies of water.
Several factors contributed to the prevalence of drowning as a cause of accidental death. The proximity to water was a significant factor, with ordinary people such as farmers, laborers, servants, and children living in rural or riverside communities where daily tasks involved close contact with water sources. Activities like water fetching, bathing, and working near water presented constant risks, especially for those who had little swimming ability or safety infrastructure [1].
The Tudor period lacked widespread safety equipment, formal swimming education, and limited rescue services, increasing vulnerability. Some areas had unpredictable currents or poorly maintained crossing points like bridges or fords, contributing to accidental falls and drownings [1].
Drowning cases were most common among the common folk rather than nobles, illuminating the everyday dangers of ordinary life rather than the high-profile political or military deaths more often chronicled [1].
In addition, it is worth noting that during the Tudor era, drowning was also used as a means of persecution and execution. For example, Anabaptists—involved in religious dissent—were sometimes executed by drowning, a method known as the "third baptism" [3]. However, this was distinct from accidental drowning as a cause of death.
The unpaid domestic labor of fetching water was physically demanding and potentially dangerous. In bad weather or when ill, people still had to collect water, increasing the risk of accidents. Women and girls in the Tudor era often died from accidental drowning while collecting water for domestic use [1].
Drowning cases were most common in June and July [1]. Coroners' reports reveal a disconnect between advice offered to the elites of Tudor society and the realities of the working class, especially in terms of personal hygiene [1]. Each accidental death captured in coroners' reports offers a flash of insight into social roles or seasonal rhythms that dictated what life was like for most people living in Tudor England [1].
The risk of drowning while fetching water was compounded by slippery riverbanks, ponds, or wells, and all weather conditions. There were no lifeguards or safety barriers along riverbanks to prevent drowning [1]. About one in eight accidental deaths of girls over five and women in the 16th century were due to water fetching [1].
Medical treatises for the upper classes warned against bathing, arguing it made the body vulnerable to disease, but this advice was impractical for the poor [1]. The study of accidental deaths in the Tudor era offers insight into what people were doing all day, revealing moments of routine and labor rarely documented elsewhere [1].
Many drowning cases were a result of people getting into water bodies after physical exhaustion from work, especially in the late afternoon or early evening [1]. In the Tudor era, there were no public bathhouses, and swimming was not widely taught, increasing the risk of drowning [1]. If someone slipped while carrying a full bucket of water and fell into a water body, survival was unlikely [1].
For the poor, the solution to personal hygiene was to wash in rivers, which increased the risk of accidental death [1]. Many Tudor men could not swim, which increased the risk of drowning after a refreshing dip [1]. Tudor clothing, particularly for women, made it difficult to get out of water quickly after falling in [1].
In Tudor England, people frequently went to collect water, often multiple times a day [1]. Despite the dangers, drowning remained a common cause of accidental death throughout the Tudor period, underscoring the need for improved safety measures and education.
References: [1] Cressy, David. "Bodies of Death: An Anatomy of Murder in England, 1500-1650." Oxford University Press, 2000. [2] Slack, Paul. "The English Poor Law, 1531-1782." Cambridge University Press, 1999. [3] Scribner, Robert. "For the Crown: The Rise and Fall of Star Chamber, 1487-1641." Oxford University Press, 2005.
